schneefink: River walking among trees, from "Safe" (Kaylee with umbrella shiny)
schneefink ([personal profile] schneefink) wrote2017-01-24 07:17 pm

The Good Place

I saw several people in my dw circle post about "The Good Place": apparently the season finale had an amazing twist, and that made me curious. It's very short so far, 13 episodes with half an hour each, so I decided to check it out.
Now some people, knowing that there was a twist coming, might try to watch carefully for clues and try to figure out what was coming. But I decided not to because it made watching more relaxed, and I wouldn't get attached to any theories that might turn out to be wrong and might spoil the surprise twist. It worked out well.

I did NOT see it coming, even though in hindsight there were SO MANY clues. (I did have a few "wouldn't it be funny if" thoughts in the right direction, but I never thought they were actually right.) I did think the set-up for the Good Place was very restrictive and it was weird that nobody except Eleanor seemed bothered by it, for example, but I thought that was just a part of the premise that they didn't think about too closely. Michael literally kicked a dog into the sun!

The reset at the end – the only way it works for me is if I imagine that they'll find each other again and find a way to escape, otherwise it's too depressing and pointless. But I'm confident they will! Mostly because of Janet, and because of the overall atmosphere of the show. I do wonder how that'll change in season 2, when the viewers know what's happening from the beginning.
If I'm very optimistic I hope for Eleanor/Tahani/Chidi.
jae: (Default)

[personal profile] jae 2017-03-06 08:27 pm (UTC)(link)
I know this is an old post, but I really wanted to make sure you saw this! It's a great interview with the creator about the season 1 finale twist. :)

http://uproxx.com/sepinwall/the-good-place-twist-explained-mike-schur/2/

-J